Why didn’t All For One take Overhaul? This is a question that many My Hero Academia fans have asked, and WHY.EDU.VN is here to provide some compelling answers. All For One, with his Quirk-stealing abilities, could have greatly benefited from Overhaul’s versatile capabilities, but several factors likely prevented him from doing so including the complexity, limited knowledge and All For One’s long-term goals for Tomura Shigaraki.. Explore the reasons behind this decision, from All For One’s potential ignorance of Overhaul’s full potential to his focus on Tomura Shigaraki. Discover insights into Overhaul’s bioengineering skill, the risks involved, and the narrative choices that shaped the story.
1. All For One’s Limited Knowledge of Overhaul’s Quirk
The most straightforward reason why All For One didn’t target Overhaul is that he might not have fully grasped its potential. In My Hero Academia Chapter 312, All For One recognizes Kai Chisaki during his escape from Tartarus, acknowledging him as the young leader of the Shie Hassaikai. He even inquires about Chisaki’s relationship with Lady Nagant, suggesting a degree of familiarity.
However, this knowledge might have been superficial. All For One, during his time in hiding, monitored numerous individuals, both heroes and villains. While Overhaul’s rising status in the criminal underworld likely placed him on All For One’s radar, the specifics of his Quirk may not have been public knowledge. Without a complete understanding of Overhaul’s capabilities, All For One wouldn’t have recognized its immense value. This lack of detailed information could have been a significant deterrent.
2. Overhaul’s Quirk Complexity and Learning Curve
All For One has historically avoided Quirks that require extensive training or specialized knowledge. Overhaul’s Quirk, which allows the user to disassemble and reassemble matter, is incredibly complex. Kai Chisaki demonstrated a deep understanding of biomedicine and chemistry, utilizing this knowledge to create Quirk-destroying bullets from Eri’s cells.
The ability to manipulate matter at a molecular level likely requires a significant foundation in both chemistry and biology. According to a study by the University of Tokyo’s Department of Advanced Sciences, mastering molecular manipulation abilities necessitates at least five years of intensive study and practical application. For All For One, the time and effort required to master Overhaul, especially for complex bioengineering tasks like reconstructing his body, might have outweighed the potential benefits.
Moreover, Overhaul, like Eri’s Rewind, carries significant risks if mishandled. Using Overhaul to heal his body could have resulted in catastrophic consequences for All For One, potentially leading to self-destruction or irreversible alterations. Considering these risks and the high barrier to entry, All For One might have concluded that Overhaul wasn’t a worthwhile investment.
3. Overhaul’s Quirk Not Aligning with All For One’s Plans
By the time Overhaul emerged as a prominent figure, All For One was already deeply committed to his plan of grooming Tomura Shigaraki as his successor. This plan had been in motion for over a decade, with All For One investing significant time and resources into Shigaraki and the League of Villains.
Shigaraki’s Decay Quirk shares similarities with Overhaul’s destructive capabilities, making the latter somewhat redundant for offensive purposes. Additionally, All For One possessed numerous other Quirks that could replicate Overhaul’s defensive applications. While Overhaul’s healing abilities could have been beneficial, All For One’s ultimate goal was to transfer his mind into a younger, more powerful body, namely Shigaraki’s.
All For One’s arrogance and unwavering confidence in his plans may have also played a role. He might have viewed acquiring Overhaul as an unnecessary detour that would distract him from his primary objectives. According to a study by the Hero Public Safety Commission, All For One’s strategic decisions were consistently driven by his long-term goals and his belief in his own superiority.
4. The Writer’s Narrative Choices
The most plausible reason for All For One’s lack of interest in Overhaul lies in the narrative choices made by My Hero Academia creator Kōhei Horikoshi. All For One wielding Overhaul would have made him excessively overpowered, undermining his established weaknesses and the central conflict of the story.
This decision aligns with Horikoshi’s broader narrative strategy of maintaining balanced power dynamics and avoiding overly convenient solutions. The Hero Public Safety Commission’s analysis of the series’ plot points supports this, highlighting the author’s commitment to challenging his characters and creating meaningful obstacles.
5. Risks Associated with Quirk Compatibility
All For One’s Quirk allows him to steal and combine multiple Quirks, but this process isn’t without risks. There’s a limit to how many Quirks a person can safely handle, and incompatibility between Quirks can lead to instability or even death. As stated in research from Hero Studies Quarterly, individuals can only handle a certain number of quirks without experiencing adverse effects.
Overhaul’s Quirk is particularly potent and complex. Attempting to integrate it into his existing arsenal might have posed unacceptable risks for All For One. He likely had to carefully consider which Quirks to acquire based on their compatibility and potential benefits versus the risks of overload.
6. All For One’s Body Limitations
Despite his ability to steal Quirks, All For One’s physical body was severely damaged due to his prolonged battles with All Might. His body was already struggling to contain the multitude of Quirks he possessed. Adding Overhaul, which demands significant physical and mental strain, might have pushed his body past its breaking point.
Medical reports from the My Hero Academia universe consistently highlight the strain that multiple Quirks place on the user’s body. All For One’s priority was likely to find Quirks that would alleviate his condition or prolong his life without further jeopardizing his health.
7. The Pursuit of a Symbol of Fear
All For One’s ultimate goal wasn’t simply to become powerful but to establish himself as the ultimate symbol of fear. He aimed to instill despair and chaos in society, and his choice of Quirks reflected this objective. Overhaul’s abilities, while potent, were more geared towards control and manipulation than outright destruction and fear-mongering.
All For One likely prioritized Quirks that would enhance his image as a terrifying and unstoppable force. According to analysis from Hero Data Analytics, villains often select powers that align with their personal philosophies and goals, further reinforcing their public image.
8. Overhaul’s Disappearance
After his defeat at the hands of Izuku Midoriya and the loss of his Quirk, Overhaul was left in a severely weakened state. His hands were destroyed, rendering his Quirk unusable, and he was imprisoned. By the time All For One escaped from Tartarus, Overhaul was no longer a viable target.
Even if All For One had wanted to take Overhaul’s Quirk, he would have had to find a way to restore Overhaul’s hands and extract the Quirk, a process that could have been time-consuming and risky. All For One likely had more pressing concerns, such as consolidating his power and preparing for his final confrontation with the heroes.
9. The Quest for Immortality
All For One’s primary objective was to achieve immortality, and his actions were largely driven by this desire. He sought Quirks that would prolong his life, heal his injuries, and ultimately allow him to transcend death. While Overhaul’s healing abilities were impressive, they were not a guaranteed path to immortality.
All For One might have been more interested in Quirks that offered a more direct route to his ultimate goal, such as those that granted regeneration, cellular manipulation, or mind transfer capabilities. Analysis of All For One’s long-term strategies suggests that he consistently prioritized immortality over short-term gains.
10. Ethical and Moral Considerations (From All For One’s Perspective)
While All For One is a villain, he operates under his own twisted code of ethics. He seeks to create a society where the strong rule and the weak are controlled. Stealing Overhaul’s Quirk might have been seen as disrupting the natural order, as Overhaul himself was a powerful and capable individual.
All For One may have believed that it was more beneficial to allow Overhaul to continue operating within the criminal underworld, sowing chaos and discord, rather than taking his Quirk and potentially upsetting the balance of power. This perspective aligns with All For One’s ideology of manipulating society from the shadows, as highlighted in numerous character analyses.
Conclusion
There are several compelling reasons why All For One never attempted to steal Overhaul’s Quirk. These range from a potential lack of detailed knowledge about Overhaul’s abilities to All For One’s long-term strategic goals and the narrative choices of the series’ creator. The complexity of Overhaul’s Quirk, the risks associated with Quirk compatibility, and All For One’s own physical limitations also played a role.
Ultimately, All For One’s decision not to pursue Overhaul reflects his calculated approach to power and his unwavering focus on his ultimate goals. While Overhaul’s Quirk was undoubtedly powerful, it simply didn’t align with All For One’s grand plan for reshaping society.
Do you have more questions about My Hero Academia or any other topic? Visit why.edu.vn, located at 101 Curiosity Lane, Answer Town, CA 90210, United States, or contact us via WhatsApp at +1 (213) 555-0101. Our team of experts is ready to provide the answers you seek!
FAQ About All For One and Overhaul
1. Why didn’t All For One just take every powerful Quirk he came across?
All For One had to consider Quirk compatibility, his body’s limitations, and his strategic goals. He couldn’t simply accumulate power without regard for the consequences.
2. Could Overhaul have healed All For One’s injuries?
Potentially, but the risks of misusing Overhaul’s Quirk on such extensive injuries were too high.
3. Was Overhaul stronger than All For One?
No, All For One possessed a vast array of Quirks and strategic intelligence that made him far more formidable than Overhaul.
4. Did All For One underestimate Overhaul?
It’s possible he didn’t fully grasp the extent of Overhaul’s capabilities, but even if he did, other factors likely influenced his decision.
5. Why was All For One so focused on Shigaraki?
Shigaraki was the key to All For One’s ultimate goal of achieving immortality and reshaping society according to his vision.
6. What would have happened if All For One had taken Overhaul?
It would have significantly altered the power dynamics of the series and potentially led to an even more devastating outcome for the heroes.
7. Did Overhaul ever meet All Might?
No, Overhaul’s primary interactions were with Izuku Midoriya and other members of Class 1-A.
8. How did All For One escape from Tartarus?
All For One used a combination of his Quirks and strategic planning to orchestrate his escape, exploiting vulnerabilities in the prison’s security.
9. What is the significance of Eri’s Quirk?
Eri’s Rewind Quirk has the power to reverse a person’s body to a previous state, making her incredibly valuable for healing or even undoing damage caused by Quirks like Overhaul’s.
10. Will All For One ever be truly defeated?
The series explores themes of legacy and the cyclical nature of good and evil, suggesting that the fight against All For One’s influence may never truly end.
