It’s common knowledge among dog owners that chocolate is off-limits for their furry friends, alongside foods like onions, garlic, grapes, and rhubarb. (And if anyone tells you dogs can’t eat grains, you might want to fact-check that!) The idea that chocolate is bad for dogs is widely understood. Yet, despite this awareness, countless dogs end up at the vet each year after sneaking a bite (or more!) of this tempting treat.
Interestingly, many other dogs manage to eat chocolate, sometimes without their owners even knowing, and remain perfectly healthy, requiring no veterinary intervention. This raises a crucial question: if chocolate is truly toxic to dogs, why are some canine chocolate lovers completely unaffected?
The answer, as with many things in toxicology, lies in the dose.
The compounds in chocolate that are harmful to dogs are theobromine and caffeine. These two substances are very similar in structure and belong to a group of chemicals known as methylxanthines.
A key reason methylxanthines are dangerous to animals is their slow metabolism, especially theobromine. In dogs, caffeine reaches peak levels in the blood within 30 to 60 minutes and is half-eliminated in about 4.5 hours. However, theobromine takes much longer. It reaches peak blood levels in about 10 hours and takes a lengthy 17.5 hours to eliminate just half of the ingested dose.
While circulating in the bloodstream, methylxanthines exert several effects. Their primary action is to block adenosine receptors. These receptors usually promote relaxation and reduce bodily activity, making us feel sleepy. By inhibiting these receptors, methylxanthines act as stimulants, counteracting sleepiness and increasing activity.
Grapefruit and Theobromine Metabolism: What’s the Connection?
Theobromine metabolism relies on enzymes from the cytochrome P450 family. You might recognize these enzymes because many common medications (like Viagra, Cialis, Erythromycin, Xanax, and many others) are processed by them, often with warnings to avoid grapefruit juice. Grapefruit contains compounds that interfere with P450 enzymes. When these enzymes are hindered, medications aren’t broken down properly, potentially leading to overdoses. These problematic compounds aren’t limited to grapefruit; they are also found in pomelos, bitter oranges, and Seville oranges used in marmalade. While dogs don’t typically eat these fruits, a dog like Marmaduke who devours marmalade alongside chocolate could face a significantly increased risk of chocolate poisoning.
So, what happens if your dog indulges in a chocolate bar? They are likely to experience nausea and vomiting, increased heart rate, diarrhea, and hyperactivity. In cases of higher methylxanthine doses, symptoms can escalate to tremors, seizures, and tragically, even death.
However, determining what constitutes a “high dose” of methylxanthines depends greatly on the individual dog.
According to the ASPCA, mild theobromine poisoning can appear at doses as low as 20 mg per kilogram of body weight (mg/kg). Severe symptoms emerge around 40 mg/kg, and seizures can occur at 60 mg/kg. The median lethal dose (LD50), the dose required to kill half of a test population, for theobromine in dogs is between 100-200 mg/kg.
Crucially, these doses are calculated per kilogram of body weight. This means a seemingly small amount of theobromine for a large German Shepherd can be a dangerously high dose for a tiny Chihuahua.
To illustrate this point, let’s meet three dogs of different sizes. First, Baci, a petite 5-year-old Maltipoo weighing 7 kg, definitely a small breed.
Next, we have Chanelle, a medium-sized 10-year-old Golden Retriever, weighing in at 25 kg.
And finally, Jupiter, a large 5-year-old Malamute/German Shepherd mix, tipping the scales at 50 kg.
Let’s consider how each of these dogs would fare if they consumed the same amount of chocolate. The chart below, calculated using an online chocolate toxicity calculator, demonstrates the varying effects.
(Green = <20 mg/kg, yellow = 20-40 mg/kg, red = 40-60 mg/kg, black = >60 mg/kg)
As you can see, while Jupiter would likely be fine after eating 1/3 cup of cocoa powder (the amount in a typical brownie recipe), Chanelle would probably get sick, and Baci could face severe symptoms like seizures and even death.
Playing with these numbers clearly shows why many dogs can eat chocolate-containing foods and remain unharmed. Chanelle could easily eat ½ cup of chocolate ice cream, a chocolate pudding cup, or a chocolate cupcake without showing any signs of illness!
Cocoa Bean Mulch: A Hidden Chocolate Hazard in Your Garden?
Cocoa-bean-based mulch has become a popular, attractive gardening option. While it can benefit your garden by adding nutrients and suppressing weeds, it poses a significant risk to your dog. Cocoa bean mulch can contain up to 32 mg of theobromine per gram, making it an even more concentrated source of theobromine than unsweetened baking chocolate. If you can’t ensure your dog won’t sample your mulch, traditional mulches are a safer bet, and they are often much cheaper!
Even if your dog seems unaffected by small amounts of chocolate, it’s still best to keep it away from them. Research has indicated that repeated exposure to theobromine can lead to cardiomyopathy in dogs, a chronic heart muscle disease that impairs the heart’s pumping ability. One study highlights this risk.
Genetic Factors in Theobromine Metabolism in Dogs
There’s evidence suggesting a genetic component influences how dogs metabolize theobromine. Dogs with a specific variant in their CYP1A2 gene (1117C>T) may have a reduced ability to break down certain substances, including lidocaine, naproxen, and theobromine. This genetic difference has important implications for veterinary treatments and could explain why some dogs become ill after consuming very small amounts of chocolate.
What to Do If Your Dog Eats Chocolate?
If you suspect your dog has eaten chocolate, you have several options. You can use an online calculator (like this one) to estimate the risk level or contact animal poison control (1-888-426-4435 in Canada and the U.S.). Remember, these tools are not a substitute for professional veterinary advice. Regardless of the calculated risk, closely monitor your dog for symptoms such as rapid heart rate, vomiting, or tremors.
Immediate veterinary attention is crucial if your dog has eaten an unknown quantity of chocolate, is showing symptoms, is pregnant (theobromine can cross the placenta and affect puppies), or has pre-existing health issues. Symptoms might not appear for up to two hours after ingestion, but anti-chocolate treatments are most effective when administered promptly.
Veterinary treatment for theobromine poisoning typically involves gastric decontamination. The first step is to empty the stomach, usually done with a drug called apomorphine, often administered through the eye for rapid absorption.
Next, activated charcoal is given. This finely powdered substance binds to various drugs and chemicals, preventing their absorption into the body. Activated charcoal is most effective when given soon after toxin ingestion and is often mixed with wet dog food (be warned: it will turn your dog’s stool black). Repeated doses of charcoal may be necessary in some cases, while a single dose suffices in others.
Beyond these initial steps, treatment focuses on managing specific symptoms. Medications like Diazepam for seizures or hyperexcitability, beta-blockers for high heart rate, or Atropine for low heart rate may be used as needed.
A Note on Cats:
Interestingly, cats are actually more susceptible to theobromine poisoning than dogs. However, we rarely hear about cats getting sick from chocolate. Why?
Primarily because cats are generally much pickier eaters than dogs. Dogs are notorious for eating almost anything they find, while cats tend to be more selective. This selectivity might be partly due to cats lacking the ability to taste glucose.
If all chocolate tasted like unsweetened dark chocolate, you probably wouldn’t eat much of it either!
Key Takeaways:
- Chocolate is poisonous to dogs mainly due to theobromine, which dogs metabolize very slowly.
- The amount of chocolate that causes symptoms varies greatly depending on the dog’s weight and the type of chocolate.
- If your dog eats chocolate, monitor them closely and seek veterinary care if they show any symptoms, or if they are young, pregnant, or have health concerns.
Special thanks to Rachel Malkani MSc. CDBC and veterinary PhD candidate, and to Henry for inspiring this article (yes, he ate chocolate!).
Want to share your thoughts on this? Visit our FB page!
