Why Not Bar, a celebrated establishment, offers a unique glimpse into Milwaukee’s tavern culture, and WHY.EDU.VN provides insightful perspectives. Dive into the history, ambiance, and community spirit that make this local favorite a must-visit spot, exploring its appeal through a detailed review of its offerings, customer experience, and historical significance. Enjoy our educational resource that satisfies your quest for answers, offering in-depth bar insights and local tavern history.
1. Unveiling the History of the Y-NOT II Bar
The Y-NOT II Bar, deeply rooted in Milwaukee’s history, offers more than just drinks; it provides an immersive experience into the city’s vibrant tavern culture. Since its establishment, this bar has become a local landmark, known for its unique atmosphere and commitment to community. Understanding its historical significance helps appreciate why it remains a beloved destination for locals and tourists alike.
The story of Y-NOT II begins with Anthony F. “Tony” DePalma, who acquired his first license for the bar. Over the years, he expanded the space to include Coffeetails. This addition allowed the establishment to extend its operating hours, serving customers from early morning until late at night.
1.1. Tony DePalma’s Vision and Expansion
Tony DePalma’s vision for Y-NOT II was to create a welcoming space where people could gather and enjoy themselves at any hour the law allowed. This vision led to the creation of Coffeetails, which opened six years ago, forty years after DePalma got his first license for the Y-NOT II. Coffeetails, with its own entrance, operates from 6 a.m. to 11 a.m., catering to early risers and those seeking a morning pick-me-up before the main bar opens. This expansion reflects DePalma’s innovative approach to adapting to changing customer needs while maintaining the bar’s original charm and spirit.
1.2. The Evolution of Coffeetails
Coffeetails began as an extension of the Y-NOT II, repurposing a small space that once housed discarded tavern and restaurant fixtures. DePalma initially intended to use the space as a liquor store, but when the laws changed, he transformed it into a coffee bar. The bar featured espresso machines, coffee grinders, and an assortment of glassware. Germaine Bowers managed the early shift, serving coffee and other beverages. The coffee grounds were donated to the Riverwest Food Pantry garden at Three Holy Women Parish’s St. Rita of Cascia Church.
The unique blend of coffee and spirits attracted a diverse clientele, including service industry workers, retirees, and those seeking a relaxed morning environment. This evolution underscores the Y-NOT II’s adaptability and commitment to serving the community in various ways.
1.3. Architectural and Cultural Significance
The physical structure of Y-NOT II, located at 706 E. Lyon St., adds to its cultural significance. Housed in a classic brick building owned by the Eichenbaum family since 1919, the tavern occupies 3,297 square feet. The building also includes apartments, a car wash, and a laundromat, reflecting Milwaukee’s early 20th-century urban landscape.
The interior features a terrazzo floor, possibly laid by Sicilian artisans, and is adorned with eclectic décor, including Route 66-upholstered settees and decades of sports schedules and campaign signs. The presence of a Genothalmic Chair and an electric chair prop from a Milwaukee Repertory Theater production adds to the bar’s quirky and unique character. These elements combine to create an atmosphere that is both nostalgic and inviting, making Y-NOT II a true Milwaukee landmark.
2. Immersive Ambiance and Décor of Why Not Bar
The ambiance and décor of the Y-NOT II Bar are integral to its unique charm and appeal. The bar is known for its eclectic mix of decorations, creating an atmosphere that is both nostalgic and inviting. From Route 66-upholstered settees to quirky art pieces, every corner of the Y-NOT II tells a story, contributing to its distinctive character. This section explores the specific elements that make the bar’s ambiance so special and memorable.
2.1. Eclectic Interior Design
The interior design of Y-NOT II is a testament to its long history and the personal touches of its owner, Tony DePalma. The bar is filled with an assortment of items collected over the years. This includes geographically incongruous Route 66-upholstered settees and decades of sports schedules. There are campaign signs for Democrats and liquor ads stapled one atop another. A folk-art bottle cap panel and a golf game machine add to the bar’s quirky appeal. The original terrazzo floor, possibly laid by Sicilian artisans, adds a touch of historical authenticity.
2.2. Unique Art and Memorabilia
The art and memorabilia at Y-NOT II contribute significantly to its immersive ambiance. The bar features an electric chair prop from the Milwaukee Repertory Theater’s 2012 production of “Assassins,” adding a dramatic and unconventional element. Each year, a plastic Santa Claus occupies the chair, creating a humorous and memorable display.
The walls are adorned with a caricature of “Poland’s Shatzie” by Peter Paris and an abundance of theater lights illuminating museum posters and postcards collected by Tony DePalma on his travels. There are photos of a ‘70s Y-NOT baseball team and Tony’s dad holding a boomba outside Alioto’s. These elements create a rich tapestry of memories and stories, making the bar feel like a living museum.
2.3. Functional and Quaint Features
In addition to its decorative elements, Y-NOT II includes functional and quaint features that enhance its ambiance. The bar has a free, small pool table with an impressive collection of cues hung from a high-quality rack dating to the ‘20s or earlier. A dart room, complete with an electronic machine and a tapestry of dogs playing poker, offers additional entertainment.
The presence of a baby grand piano, currently used to support a large flat-screen television, adds to the bar’s eclectic charm. Mirrors reflect the “Y-NOT” neon signs, creating a playful visual effect. A giant fan mounted on a large base keeps the air circulating, adding to the bar’s comfortable and welcoming atmosphere.
3. The Unique Drink Selection at Why Not Bar
The drink selection at the Y-NOT II Bar is as unique and eclectic as its ambiance. Known for its affordable prices and unusual offerings, the bar caters to a diverse clientele with a variety of tastes. From liter beers served in ponderous mugs to airplane bottles of various spirits, the Y-NOT II offers a drinking experience that is both memorable and budget-friendly. This section explores the specific elements that make the bar’s drink selection stand out.
3.1. Signature Drinks
The Y-NOT II is known for its signature drinks that have become favorites among regulars and newcomers alike. The boomba, a stemmed beer glass with a spherical bowl that holds a pint, is a popular choice. Liter beers, sold for as little as $3.75, are served in large mugs. These offerings provide a unique and affordable drinking experience.
Another notable feature is the availability of airplane bottles of various spirits, priced as low as 2 for $7. Customers can mix their own drinks with available “set-ups,” adding to the bar’s laid-back and self-service atmosphere.
3.2. Variety of Beers on Tap
The Y-NOT II offers a variety of beers on tap to cater to different preferences. There are eight taps from an antique brass dispenser and four taps (mostly Sprecher specialties when available) in a Perlick dispenser. If plastic cups are inverted over a tap handle, customers are encouraged to ask the bartender about that particular variety.
The availability of both domestic and craft beers ensures that there is something for everyone. The affordable prices, such as a can of PBR for $3.50, make the Y-NOT II an attractive destination for budget-conscious drinkers.
3.3. Unique Drinking Experience
The Y-NOT II offers a unique drinking experience that sets it apart from other bars. The combination of affordable prices, unusual offerings, and a relaxed atmosphere makes it a popular choice for locals and tourists alike. The ability to mix your own drinks with airplane bottles and the availability of liter beers in ponderous mugs create a memorable and enjoyable experience.
The bar’s commitment to providing a diverse and affordable drink selection reflects its dedication to serving the community and creating a welcoming space for all.
4. The Community and Clientele of Why Not Bar
The community and clientele of the Y-NOT II Bar are integral to its identity and appeal. Over the years, the bar has cultivated a diverse and loyal following, ranging from service industry workers to retirees. The welcoming atmosphere and affordable prices make it a popular gathering place for people from all walks of life. This section explores the specific elements that make the bar’s community so special and vibrant.
4.1. Diverse Regulars
The Y-NOT II is known for its diverse group of regulars who contribute to its unique atmosphere. Early regulars at Coffeetails include service industry workers, often still up from late shifts, and retirees. There is also a cadre of young folks who work at Topper’s, delivering pizzas until 4 a.m.
The bar attracts a mix of people, including gays and those for whom employment has proved elusive or unnecessary. This diversity adds to the bar’s welcoming and inclusive environment, making it a place where everyone feels comfortable and accepted.
4.2. Community Events and Gatherings
The Y-NOT II hosts various community events and gatherings that foster a sense of belonging and camaraderie. Wednesday afternoons, Tony DePalma and his buddies gather for penny stakes card games, a little bite to eat, and maybe something to drink. This is the time to sample the fancy Scotch and Port that the liquor dealers are trying to sell.
The bar has also been the site of memorial celebrations, reflecting its role as a community hub. These events underscore the Y-NOT II’s commitment to providing a space where people can come together to celebrate life and support one another.
4.3. The Role of Tony DePalma
Tony DePalma plays a central role in shaping the community and clientele of the Y-NOT II. As the owner and host, he creates a welcoming and friendly atmosphere that attracts a diverse group of people. His personal touches, such as the eclectic décor and affordable drink prices, reflect his commitment to serving the community.
DePalma’s dedication to providing a space where people can gather and enjoy themselves has made the Y-NOT II a beloved institution in Milwaukee. His presence and personality are integral to the bar’s identity and appeal.
5. Special Events and Offerings at Why Not Bar
The Y-NOT II Bar is known for its special events and offerings that enhance its appeal and create a memorable experience for its patrons. From free popcorn to occasional four-star free buffets, the bar provides a variety of perks that set it apart from other establishments. This section explores the specific elements that make the bar’s special events and offerings so unique and appreciated.
5.1. Free Popcorn and Buffets
One of the most appreciated offerings at the Y-NOT II is the free popcorn available in a brightly lit machine. The bar also occasionally provides a four-star free buffet that is better than what you can actually pay for in restaurants in some other cities. These offerings add to the bar’s welcoming and generous atmosphere, making it a popular choice for those seeking a casual and affordable experience.
The buffets often feature grilled corn and chickens, cooked on a giant grill salvaged from a blast foundry. These feasts are often accompanied by food brought in by customers and topped by Sicilian goodies from Tony DePalma’s nearby kitchen.
5.2. Grill Outs and Special Feasts
The Y-NOT II is known for its grill outs and special feasts that bring the community together. Tony DePalma is often seen working the grill out on the street, cooking dozens of ears of corn and chickens until they are served in the bar. These events are a highlight for many patrons, providing a festive and communal dining experience.
The feasts are often accompanied by food brought in by customers, creating a collaborative and diverse spread. The combination of delicious food, affordable drinks, and a welcoming atmosphere makes these events a memorable part of the Y-NOT II experience.
5.3. Unique and Memorable Anecdotes
The Y-NOT II is full of unique and memorable anecdotes that reflect its character and appeal. One such anecdote involves a member of Tony’s Wednesday afternoon card club who died. Arrangements were made to hold a memorial celebration at the tavern, but a family member insisted on moving the wake to a hotel because the Y-NOT II was not “tony enough.”
Rather than cancel the event, the buffet went on the table, and all the patrons were invited to have their share of the funeral feast that was not to be. It was a celebration of life, with Tony DePalma as host, underscoring the bar’s role as a community hub and its commitment to providing a welcoming space for all.
6. Why Not Bar: A Cultural Hub in Milwaukee
The Y-NOT II Bar stands as a cultural hub in Milwaukee, reflecting the city’s history, community spirit, and unique character. Over the years, the bar has become more than just a place to drink; it has evolved into a gathering place where people from all walks of life come together to share stories, celebrate life, and support one another. This section explores the specific elements that make the bar a cultural landmark in Milwaukee.
6.1. Reflection of Milwaukee’s History
The Y-NOT II reflects Milwaukee’s history through its architecture, décor, and long-standing presence in the community. Housed in a classic brick building dating back to 1919, the bar is a tangible link to the city’s past. The eclectic interior, filled with vintage items and memorabilia, tells a story of Milwaukee’s changing landscape and cultural evolution.
The bar’s commitment to providing affordable drinks and a welcoming atmosphere reflects the city’s working-class roots and its tradition of community-oriented establishments. The Y-NOT II serves as a reminder of Milwaukee’s rich history and its enduring spirit.
6.2. Community Spirit and Inclusivity
The Y-NOT II embodies community spirit and inclusivity through its diverse clientele and welcoming atmosphere. The bar attracts people from all walks of life, creating a melting pot of stories and experiences. The affordable prices and laid-back environment make it a place where everyone feels comfortable and accepted.
The bar’s commitment to hosting community events and gatherings, such as penny stakes card games and memorial celebrations, underscores its role as a hub for social interaction and support. The Y-NOT II stands as a testament to Milwaukee’s strong sense of community and its dedication to inclusivity.
6.3. Unique Character and Appeal
The Y-NOT II possesses a unique character and appeal that sets it apart from other bars in Milwaukee. The combination of its eclectic décor, affordable prices, and welcoming atmosphere creates an experience that is both memorable and authentic. The bar’s commitment to providing a diverse and unusual selection of drinks and events reflects its dedication to innovation and creativity.
The Y-NOT II’s long-standing presence in the community and its role as a gathering place for people from all walks of life have made it a beloved institution in Milwaukee. Its unique character and appeal make it a true cultural landmark in the city.
7. Customer Experiences and Reviews of Why Not Bar
Customer experiences and reviews of the Y-NOT II Bar provide valuable insights into its appeal and reputation. Patrons consistently praise the bar for its unique atmosphere, affordable prices, and welcoming community. This section explores common themes and sentiments expressed in customer reviews and testimonials.
7.1. Positive Feedback on Atmosphere
Many customers highlight the Y-NOT II’s unique and eclectic atmosphere as a major draw. They appreciate the bar’s quirky décor, vintage items, and memorabilia, which create a nostalgic and immersive experience. The presence of items like the electric chair prop and the Route 66-upholstered settees adds to the bar’s distinctive charm.
Customers often describe the atmosphere as relaxed, laid-back, and unpretentious, making it a comfortable place to unwind and socialize. The bar’s commitment to maintaining its unique character is consistently praised in customer reviews.
7.2. Appreciation for Affordable Prices
Affordable prices are another common theme in customer reviews of the Y-NOT II. Patrons appreciate the bar’s commitment to providing budget-friendly drinks and events, making it accessible to a wide range of people. The availability of liter beers for as little as $3.75 and airplane bottles of spirits for 2 for $7 is particularly popular.
Customers often note that the Y-NOT II offers a great value for the money, making it an attractive destination for those seeking a casual and affordable experience. The bar’s commitment to providing budget-friendly options is consistently praised in customer reviews.
7.3. Praise for Welcoming Community
The welcoming community at the Y-NOT II is consistently praised by customers. Patrons appreciate the bar’s diverse and inclusive atmosphere, where people from all walks of life come together to share stories and support one another. The presence of regulars, who contribute to the bar’s friendly and convivial environment, is often noted in customer reviews.
Customers often describe the Y-NOT II as a place where they feel like they belong, making it a popular gathering place for those seeking social interaction and camaraderie. The bar’s commitment to fostering a welcoming community is consistently praised in customer reviews.
8. Comparing Why Not Bar to Other Milwaukee Taverns
Comparing the Y-NOT II Bar to other Milwaukee taverns highlights its unique attributes and distinguishing characteristics. While Milwaukee boasts a rich tavern culture with numerous establishments offering their own distinct experiences, the Y-NOT II stands out for its eclectic atmosphere, affordable prices, and strong sense of community. This section explores the specific elements that differentiate the Y-NOT II from its competitors.
8.1. Unique Ambiance vs. Traditional Taverns
Many Milwaukee taverns offer a traditional, no-frills atmosphere, focusing on classic décor and straightforward service. In contrast, the Y-NOT II distinguishes itself with its eclectic and quirky ambiance, filled with vintage items, memorabilia, and unconventional art pieces. The presence of items like the electric chair prop and the Route 66-upholstered settees creates a unique and memorable experience that is not found in traditional taverns.
While traditional taverns may appeal to those seeking a familiar and predictable environment, the Y-NOT II attracts customers who appreciate its distinctive character and unconventional charm. The bar’s commitment to maintaining its unique atmosphere sets it apart from its competitors.
8.2. Affordability vs. Upscale Bars
Milwaukee’s bar scene includes a range of establishments, from budget-friendly taverns to upscale bars offering premium drinks and sophisticated environments. The Y-NOT II distinguishes itself with its commitment to affordability, providing budget-friendly drinks and events that are accessible to a wide range of people. The availability of liter beers for as little as $3.75 and airplane bottles of spirits for 2 for $7 makes it an attractive destination for those seeking a casual and affordable experience.
While upscale bars may offer a more luxurious and refined experience, the Y-NOT II attracts customers who prioritize affordability and value. The bar’s commitment to providing budget-friendly options sets it apart from its competitors.
8.3. Community Focus vs. Tourist Destinations
Some Milwaukee taverns cater primarily to tourists, offering generic experiences and mass-produced products. In contrast, the Y-NOT II distinguishes itself with its strong focus on community, serving as a gathering place for locals and fostering a sense of belonging and camaraderie. The bar’s commitment to hosting community events and gatherings, such as penny stakes card games and memorial celebrations, underscores its role as a hub for social interaction and support.
While tourist destinations may offer a more commercialized and superficial experience, the Y-NOT II attracts customers who value authenticity and community. The bar’s commitment to fostering a welcoming community sets it apart from its competitors.
9. Navigating to Why Not Bar: Location and Accessibility
Navigating to the Y-NOT II Bar is straightforward, given its central location and accessibility. Situated in a vibrant neighborhood, the bar is easily reachable by various means of transportation. Understanding its location and accessibility can help potential visitors plan their trip and enjoy their experience without any hassle.
9.1. Address and General Location
The Y-NOT II Bar is located at 706 E. Lyon St. and Coffeetails is located at 1506 N. Van Buren St. These establishments are in a bustling area of Milwaukee, known for its mix of residential and commercial properties. The central location makes it easily accessible from various parts of the city.
The bar is situated in a classic brick building that has been a part of the neighborhood since 1919, adding to its historical and cultural significance. The surrounding area includes apartments, a car wash, and a laundromat, reflecting Milwaukee’s urban landscape.
9.2. Transportation Options
Various transportation options are available for reaching the Y-NOT II Bar, catering to different preferences and needs. Public transportation is a convenient option, with bus routes serving the area. The Street Smart Walk Score is 93 out of 100, indicating a “Walker’s Paradise,” and the Transit Score is 58 out of 100, indicating “Good Transit.” Route 15 stops outside the door.
For those who prefer driving, street parking is available in the vicinity, although it may be limited during peak hours. Ride-sharing services like Uber and Lyft are also readily available, providing a convenient and reliable transportation option.
9.3. Nearby Landmarks and Attractions
The Y-NOT II Bar is located near several landmarks and attractions, making it a convenient stop for those exploring the area. The Riverwest Food Pantry garden at Three Holy Women Parish’s St. Rita of Cascia Church is nearby, offering a glimpse into the community’s commitment to social services.
The Milwaukee Repertory Theater is also in the vicinity, adding to the area’s cultural appeal. The bar’s central location makes it a convenient destination for those visiting these and other nearby attractions.
10. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Why Not Bar
This section addresses frequently asked questions about the Y-NOT II Bar, providing potential visitors with essential information and insights. These FAQs cover various aspects of the bar, from its history and ambiance to its special offerings and customer experiences.
10.1. What is the history of the Y-NOT II Bar?
The Y-NOT II Bar was established by Anthony F. “Tony” DePalma, who acquired his first license for the bar. Over the years, he expanded the space to include Coffeetails. This addition allowed the establishment to extend its operating hours, serving customers from early morning until late at night. The bar has been a fixture in Milwaukee’s tavern scene for many years, reflecting the city’s history and community spirit.
10.2. What makes the ambiance of the Y-NOT II Bar unique?
The ambiance of the Y-NOT II Bar is unique due to its eclectic mix of decorations, vintage items, and unconventional art pieces. The presence of items like the electric chair prop and the Route 66-upholstered settees creates a memorable and immersive experience. The bar’s commitment to maintaining its unique character sets it apart from other establishments.
10.3. What are some signature drinks offered at the Y-NOT II Bar?
Some signature drinks offered at the Y-NOT II Bar include the boomba, a stemmed beer glass with a spherical bowl that holds a pint, and liter beers served in large mugs. The bar also offers airplane bottles of various spirits, allowing customers to mix their own drinks with available “set-ups.” These offerings provide a unique and affordable drinking experience.
10.4. What type of community and clientele does the Y-NOT II Bar attract?
The Y-NOT II Bar attracts a diverse community and clientele, ranging from service industry workers to retirees. The bar’s welcoming atmosphere and affordable prices make it a popular gathering place for people from all walks of life. The presence of regulars, who contribute to the bar’s friendly and convivial environment, is a defining characteristic.
10.5. What special events and offerings are available at the Y-NOT II Bar?
Special events and offerings at the Y-NOT II Bar include free popcorn, occasional four-star free buffets, and grill outs featuring grilled corn and chickens. These events bring the community together and provide a memorable dining experience. The bar’s commitment to providing a diverse and affordable selection of events and offerings reflects its dedication to serving the community.
10.6. How does the Y-NOT II Bar compare to other Milwaukee taverns?
The Y-NOT II Bar distinguishes itself from other Milwaukee taverns through its unique ambiance, affordable prices, and strong sense of community. While many taverns offer a traditional atmosphere, the Y-NOT II stands out with its eclectic décor and unconventional charm. Its commitment to providing budget-friendly options and fostering a welcoming community sets it apart from its competitors.
10.7. How can I navigate to the Y-NOT II Bar?
The Y-NOT II Bar is located at 706 E. Lyon St. and Coffeetails is located at 1506 N. Van Buren St. in a central area of Milwaukee. Various transportation options are available, including public transportation, street parking, and ride-sharing services. The bar’s central location makes it easily accessible from various parts of the city.
10.8. What are the operating hours of the Y-NOT II Bar and Coffeetails?
The operating hours of the Y-NOT II Bar and Coffeetails are as follows: Sunday – Thursday 6am – 2am, Friday – Saturday 6am – 2:30am. Open 44 hours straight at New Years. Coffeetails operates from 6 a.m. to 11 a.m., while the Y-NOT II opens at 11 a.m. and stays open until late at night.
10.9. Does the Y-NOT II Bar offer any games or entertainment?
Yes, the Y-NOT II Bar offers various games and entertainment options, including a free, small pool table, an electronic dartboard, a golf game, cribbage, chess, checkers, and many board games upon request. These options provide a diverse range of entertainment for patrons.
10.10. Is the Y-NOT II Bar a pet-friendly establishment?
The Y-NOT II Bar has a mascot named Remy, a white poodle, who is successor to the long-lived Ralph, a 13-year-old black poodle. While the bar may not be explicitly pet-friendly for all animals, the presence of a mascot suggests a welcoming attitude towards animals and their owners.
11. Why You Should Visit the Why Not Bar
The Y-NOT II Bar offers a unique and compelling experience that makes it a must-visit destination. From its eclectic ambiance and affordable prices to its welcoming community and special events, the bar provides a memorable and authentic taste of Milwaukee’s tavern culture. This section highlights the key reasons why you should make a point of visiting the Y-NOT II.
11.1. Experience a Unique Milwaukee Landmark
Visiting the Y-NOT II Bar allows you to experience a unique Milwaukee landmark that has been a part of the city’s history for many years. The bar’s classic brick building, vintage décor, and unconventional art pieces create an atmosphere that is both nostalgic and immersive. Stepping into the Y-NOT II is like stepping back in time, offering a glimpse into Milwaukee’s rich cultural heritage.
11.2. Enjoy an Affordable and Welcoming Atmosphere
The Y-NOT II Bar offers an affordable and welcoming atmosphere that is accessible to people from all walks of life. The bar’s budget-friendly drinks and events make it an attractive destination for those seeking a casual and unpretentious experience. The welcoming community, diverse clientele, and friendly staff create an environment where everyone feels comfortable and accepted.
11.3. Participate in Special Events and Community Gatherings
Visiting the Y-NOT II Bar allows you to participate in special events and community gatherings that foster a sense of belonging and camaraderie. From free popcorn and buffets to grill outs and memorial celebrations, the bar provides a variety of opportunities for social interaction and support. These events underscore the Y-NOT II’s role as a community hub and its commitment to providing a welcoming space for all.
Are you curious to learn more about Milwaukee’s hidden gems like the Y-NOT II Bar or need answers to burning questions about local culture and history? Don’t let your curiosity go unanswered. Visit WHY.EDU.VN today to ask your questions and connect with experts who can provide the insights you seek. Whether you’re a local resident or a curious traveler, WHY.EDU.VN is your go-to resource for exploring the world around you.
Address: 101 Curiosity Lane, Answer Town, CA 90210, United States
WhatsApp: +1 (213) 555-0101
Website: why.edu.vn
