The chilling Halloween saga is anchored by the relentless killing sprees of Michael Myers, with Laurie Strode (Jamie Lee Curtis) frequently positioned as his primary target. Over the decades and across various timelines, the reasons behind Michael’s fixation on Laurie have shifted and evolved, adding layers of complexity to their terrifying dynamic. Since John Carpenter unleashed Halloween in 1978, a film that redefined the slasher genre, Michael Myers has become an iconic figure of horror. We were introduced to a young Michael who, on Halloween night 1963, murdered his sister Judith. Institutionalized under the care of Dr. Sam Loomis, Michael remained silent until his escape on October 30, 1978. His return to Haddonfield set the stage for his initial terrifying encounter with Laurie Strode and the beginning of his deadly obsession.
While Laurie Strode has been Michael Myers’ central obsession in many Halloween iterations, including retcons and Rob Zombie’s remakes, the core question remains: why Laurie? What drives Michael’s relentless pursuit? Several theories attempt to dissect this deadly dynamic, ranging from chance encounters to deeper, more sinister connections.
Chance Encounter: Laurie Was Simply in the Wrong Place
Laurie Was In The Wrong Place At The Wrong Time
In John Carpenter’s original masterpiece, Michael Myers’ initial motive for killing his sister remains chillingly ambiguous, portraying him as an almost supernatural embodiment of evil capable of indiscriminate violence. This sense of motiveless dread carries over to his return to Haddonfield. Michael takes refuge in his abandoned childhood home, which, fatefully, is being prepared for sale by Laurie Strode’s father.
It is here that Laurie’s path tragically intersects with Michael’s. As Laurie drops off keys at the Myers house, a task related to her father’s involvement in selling the property, she unknowingly catches Michael’s attention. This seemingly innocuous moment, Laurie simply performing a chore, marks the genesis of Michael’s fixation. He observes her, then begins to stalk her. Laurie’s first terrifying glimpse of “The Boogeyman” occurs in a classroom window – Michael, across the street, watching her intently. This theory posits a disturbingly random origin for Michael’s obsession: Laurie’s misfortune was simply being seen by Michael Myers at a crucial moment.
The Sibling Twist: A Controversial Connection Introduced in Halloween II
Laurie Was Michael’s Other Sister
The original Halloween‘s terror stemmed partly from Michael’s seemingly arbitrary choice of Laurie as his target. Halloween II dramatically shifted this narrative by introducing a familial link: Laurie was Michael’s younger sister. This controversial revelation explained that after Judith’s murder, Michael’s parents died in a car accident, leading to Laurie’s adoption by the Strodes.
While Halloween II established this sibling connection, it didn’t fully clarify how Michael recognized Laurie as his sister. Later sequels attempted to elaborate, particularly Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers, which introduced the Cult of Thorn. This cult, believing in a demon called Thorn that spreads misfortune, cursed a child from their tribe to kill their family on Samhain. In this convoluted storyline, the Myers family was implicated in this curse, and Laurie, as Michael’s sister, became a target within this supernatural framework.
Halloween why Michael Myers doesn
The sibling connection carried through timelines like Halloween H20 and Halloween: Resurrection, which acted as sequels to Halloween II. Rob Zombie’s remakes also incorporated the sister storyline, even adding a ghostly presence of their mother. However, the Halloween reboot trilogy, starting in 2018, discarded the sibling link, with Laurie’s granddaughter dismissing it as media fabrication, returning to a non-familial dynamic.
The Unkillable Target: Obsession Fueled by Resistance
Laurie Strode Was Always The Final Girl
Regardless of the initial reason, Laurie Strode proved far from an easy victim. Throughout the Halloween saga, Laurie repeatedly survives encounters with Michael, becoming increasingly resilient. Despite being seemingly killed multiple times across different timelines (though only once by Michael himself on screen, in Halloween: Resurrection), Laurie’s survival against Michael’s onslaught becomes a defining aspect of their relationship.
Her repeated survival transformed their dynamic. It moved beyond a simple predator-prey scenario into a protracted battle of wills. Laurie’s increasing ability to evade and confront Michael seemed to intensify his obsession. The dynamic evolved into a war of attrition, a deadly game to determine who was stronger and more cunning. This perspective suggests Michael’s fixation deepened not just because of who Laurie was, but because of her defiance and resilience against him. In the reboot timeline, Laurie’s arc culminates in her seemingly final victory over Michael, highlighting her transformation from victim to ultimate survivor.
Annie Brackett: A Case for Mistaken Identity?
Theory: Annie Was Michael Myers’ Target In Halloween, Not Laurie
While Laurie is consistently presented as Michael’s primary target, a compelling fan theory suggests Annie Brackett, Laurie’s friend, might have been Michael’s original intended victim in the 1978 film. This theory points to several subtle clues within the original Halloween.
The theory highlights the scene where Michael drives past Laurie, Annie, and Lynda, slowing down as he passes them. Annie, in a moment of teenage bravado, yells at the car, “Hey jerk! Speed kills!” This interaction, though seemingly minor, could have drawn Michael’s attention specifically to Annie. Later, as the girls babysit, Michael’s actions further fuel this theory. He goes to the Wallace house, where Annie is babysitting, and is seen watching her enter.
After Annie drops Lindsey off at the Doyles’, Michael attacks and kills her in her car. It’s only after Laurie goes to check on Annie that Michael shifts his focus to pursuing Laurie. Furthermore, the theory emphasizes the disturbing detail of Michael placing Annie’s body on the bed with Judith’s gravestone. This act could suggest Annie, not Laurie, was meant to symbolically mirror Judith, making Annie the intended target all along, and Laurie a secondary target who emerged after Annie’s death.
Home Invasion: Defending His Territory
Theory: Michael Myers Went After Laurie Because She Disturbed His Home
Another theory, particularly relevant to the Halloween reboot trilogy, proposes that Michael’s targeting of Laurie stems from her connection to his childhood home. Halloween Kills emphasized Michael’s singular drive to return home, even violently eliminating the current residents. In the original 1978 Halloween, Laurie’s role in dropping off the Myers house keys, due to her father’s involvement in selling the property, becomes significant in this context.
This theory posits that Michael viewed Laurie’s actions as a disturbance, an intrusion upon his territory. His subsequent murders in the 2018 and Halloween Kills films can be interpreted as him clearing a path back to his home, eliminating anyone in his way. While Halloween Ends somewhat deviates from this “return home” narrative, this theory offers a compelling alternative to the sibling connection, suggesting Michael’s motive is rooted in territorial defense rather than a personal vendetta against Laurie specifically.
Repressed Desires: A Psychological Interpretation
Theory: Michael Myers Represents Laurie’s Repressed Desires
A more psychological theory interprets Michael’s targeting of Laurie through the lens of slasher film tropes and repressed desires. Slasher films often punish “bad kids” who deviate from societal norms, while Laurie in Halloween embodies the “good girl” archetype. However, this theory suggests Michael might be acting out Laurie’s subconscious desires and frustrations.
Michael’s initial victims in Halloween could be seen as individuals who, in some way, are connected to or even victimize Laurie. He attacks bullies who bother Tommy Doyle, and Annie, who leaves Laurie with the babysitting duties to meet her boyfriend. From this perspective, Michael is punishing those who disrupt Laurie’s ordered world. When Laurie experiences guilt and trauma from these deaths, Michael then turns his attention to her, perhaps as a manifestation of her own repressed feelings of anger or resentment towards those who disrupt her “good girl” persona.
Indiscriminate Evil: Laurie as a Random Victim
Theory: Michael Myers Doesn’t Even Care About Laurie
Finally, a starkly different theory proposes that Michael’s pursuit of Laurie is not deeply personal at all. In the original Halloween, Michael’s victims are varied, suggesting he is terrorizing the town indiscriminately before encountering Laurie. This theory suggests Laurie might simply have been his next random target, with no specific motive beyond opportunity.
The intense trauma of being targeted by a serial killer, however, could lead Laurie to believe she is uniquely targeted, creating a personal narrative out of random violence. Perhaps, in this view, Laurie’s perception of being haunted by Michael is a psychological response to inexplicable terror, a way to rationalize the irrational. In Halloween II, the narrative shifts to revenge as a motive after Michael is injured in the first film, and later, it becomes almost a reciprocal hunt, with Laurie actively pursuing Michael as much as he pursues her.
Ultimately, the enduring terror of Michael Myers may lie precisely in the ambiguity of his motives. While the Halloween franchise offers various explanations for his fixation on Laurie Strode, the lack of a single, definitive answer contributes to his mystique as an embodiment of senseless, unstoppable evil.
[
