Walking, often hailed as a cornerstone of a healthy lifestyle, can become a source of frustration and discomfort when leg pain enters the equation. Instead of enjoying the stride and the scenery, you might find yourself hobbling and wondering, “Why Do My Legs Ache when I walk?”. It’s a common complaint, and while fitness enthusiasts once championed high-intensity workouts, modern understanding emphasizes the profound benefits of regular, moderate activity like walking. Walking is accessible, convenient, and requires minimal gear – just a good pair of shoes. However, for many, leg pain transforms this simple act into an ordeal, making even a leisurely stroll seem impossible.
The notion of a “brisk” walk, recommended at three to four miles per hour for optimal health, becomes a distant dream when leg pain sets in. Whether due to age or other underlying factors, various conditions can trigger leg pain after walking, significantly hindering mobility. While familiar culprits like arthritis readily come to mind, other less-known conditions, such as peripheral artery disease, can also be responsible.
This article delves into four non-arthritic conditions that commonly cause leg pain, impacting your ability to walk comfortably. We’ll explore these conditions, their symptoms, and effective management strategies, so you don’t have to simply endure the pain and limit your life.
Understanding Leg Pain: Conditions Beyond Arthritis
It’s important to note that while we discuss these conditions individually, it’s not uncommon for individuals to experience two or more simultaneously. This overlap can complicate diagnosis and treatment, highlighting the need for a comprehensive understanding of potential causes.
1. Peripheral Artery Disease (PAD)
Peripheral artery disease (PAD) is a manifestation of atherosclerosis, the same process that underlies most strokes and heart attacks. In atherosclerosis, plaque composed of fat and cholesterol accumulates within arteries, causing them to narrow. Blood clots can further obstruct these narrowed arteries. In PAD, the arteries primarily affected are those supplying blood to the leg muscles. Risk factors for PAD mirror those for heart disease and stroke, including smoking, high cholesterol, high blood pressure, and particularly diabetes.
The hallmark symptom of PAD is intermittent claudication – a cramping, tight pain felt in the muscles “downstream” from the narrowed artery. This pain can manifest in the buttocks, thigh, calf, or foot, with the calf being the most frequent location. Characteristically, the pain emerges during walking, intensifies until walking ceases, and subsides with rest. Much like angina (chest pain due to heart artery blockage), PAD pain stems from oxygen deprivation in working muscle cells caused by restricted blood flow. The term “intermittent claudication” itself is derived from the Latin “claudicatio,” meaning limping. However, PAD can present with other types of leg discomfort, such as a feeling of heaviness or easy fatigue. Often, individuals unconsciously reduce their activity levels to avoid pain, masking the underlying problem.
Signs of PAD include a weakened pulse below the narrowed artery, slow-healing scratches or bruises on the lower leg, and skin that feels pale and cool. Diagnosis typically involves the ankle-brachial index (ABI), which compares blood pressure at the ankle to that in the arm. Normally, these measurements are similar. However, in PAD, ankle blood pressure will be lower due to reduced blood flow.
PAD is not only a serious condition in itself, causing pain and disability, but it also serves as a critical warning sign for broader cardiovascular disease. Atherosclerosis in the legs often indicates its presence elsewhere in the body. Individuals with PAD are at a significantly elevated risk – six to seven times more likely – of experiencing a heart attack, stroke, or transient ischemic attack (TIA) compared to those without PAD. A PAD diagnosis should prompt aggressive management of cardiovascular risk factors.
While walking may be painful, complete rest isn’t the answer. Structured, supervised exercise programs have proven effective in increasing walking distance before pain onset. These programs typically involve walking until pain emerges (even if it’s just for a few minutes), resting until the pain subsides, and then resuming walking. These walk-rest-walk cycles are most beneficial when performed for approximately 30 minutes, several times a week.
Low-dose aspirin (75 mg to 81 mg) is often recommended to mitigate the risk of heart attack and stroke in PAD patients. Clopidogrel (Plavix), another antiplatelet drug for those with aspirin allergies, reduces blood clot formation. Cilostazol (Pletal) may improve pain-free walking distance in some individuals.
Severe PAD can cause leg pain even at rest, particularly in the feet. In the most critical cases, PAD can lead to tissue death and gangrene.
For severe PAD or cases unresponsive to exercise and medication, procedures like angioplasty to reopen blocked arteries or bypass surgery using a blood vessel graft to reroute blood flow around the blockage may be considered. However, the long-term success of these revascularization procedures is variable, and some studies suggest structured exercise programs can yield comparable, or even superior, outcomes.
2. Chronic Venous Insufficiency (CVI)
Similar to PAD, chronic venous insufficiency (CVI) involves impaired circulation, but it affects the veins, specifically hindering blood’s return journey to the heart and lungs.
Unlike arteries, which actively pump blood, veins are more passive. In the legs, the muscles surrounding the veins are crucial, providing the pumping force that drains superficial veins and propels blood upwards through deeper veins towards the heart. Tiny valves within veins regulate pressure and prevent backflow.
In CVI, these valves are damaged, causing blood to pool in the legs and feet instead of flowing efficiently towards the heart. This creates a vicious cycle: valve damage leads to increased venous pressure and vein stretching, further impairing valve closure and exacerbating backflow and pressure.
Swollen feet and ankles are the most common symptom of CVI. Persistent fluid buildup in the legs can also lead to skin inflammation (dermatitis), skin ulcers, and increased susceptibility to skin infections (cellulitis). Legs may feel heavy or achy. During walking, individuals may experience an uncomfortable leg tightness.
Elevating the legs above heart level, such as lying down with pillows under the legs, can alleviate CVI symptoms by promoting blood flow towards the heart. While sitting for extended periods, ankle pumps (pointing toes up and down) can activate leg muscles and improve venous drainage.
Compression stockings, tighter at the ankle than the knee, are highly effective in reducing swelling and discomfort. These stockings must be significantly tighter than standard anti-embolism stockings used in hospitals. Their tightness can make them difficult to put on; washing new stockings or using talcum powder or thin stockings underneath can ease application.
There are no specific medications for CVI itself. However, surgical treatments have advanced significantly. Modern varicose vein therapy has moved away from traditional saphenous vein stripping, an invasive procedure involving groin and leg incisions, vein removal, general anesthesia, hospitalization, and prolonged recovery.
Current treatments focus on minimally invasive vein closure rather than removal. Techniques include catheter-based procedures performed under ultrasound guidance and local anesthesia in outpatient settings. Patients can typically walk immediately after these treatments.
3. Lumbar Spinal Stenosis
Stenosis, in medical terms, refers to narrowing. Lumbar spinal stenosis involves narrowing within the lumbar spine – the lower back region composed of five vertebrae. This narrowing can result from changes in vertebrae, intervertebral discs, or supporting structures, impinging on the spinal canal that houses the spinal cord and nerve roots. Pain arises from mechanical pressure and potentially from compromised blood flow to nerves.
While lower back pain can occur with lumbar spinal stenosis, leg pain is often the predominant symptom. This pain can resemble PAD-related pain: cramping tightness that worsens with walking, though it’s frequently felt in the thigh rather than the calf. Leg weakness and numbness may also be present.
Historically, leg pain from lumbar stenosis was termed pseudo-claudication to differentiate it from artery-related claudication, as spinal causes were not initially understood. The preferred term now is neurogenic claudication, indicating a nervous system origin.
Diagnosis begins with discussing symptoms and medical history. A key diagnostic clue is pain relief upon forward bending or spinal flexion. This posture reduces pressure on the lumbar region, explaining why some individuals with lumbar spinal stenosis find walking easier while leaning on a shopping cart or walker.
MRI or CT scans are often used to confirm the diagnosis, but imaging alone shouldn’t dictate diagnosis, as many individuals have asymptomatic spinal stenosis detected on imaging.
Treatment typically starts with physical therapy and exercises to strengthen back and abdominal muscles. Pain relievers may provide symptomatic relief. Corticosteroid injections into the spine can offer temporary pain reduction but are not a long-term solution.
If pain persists, surgery is an option. Laminectomy, the most common procedure, involves removing a portion of a vertebra to create more space for the spinal cord and nerves. Bone spurs and parts of discs and facet joints can also be removed to alleviate pressure.
4. Diabetic Neuropathy
People with diabetes are susceptible to nerve damage, or neuropathy. The exact mechanism is not fully understood, but high blood sugar levels may damage the small blood vessels that nourish nerves with oxygen and nutrients. Diabetes may also deplete neurotrophic peptides, chemicals vital for nerve tissue repair and regeneration.
Diabetic neuropathy affects the upper and lower legs differently. Upper leg nerve damage can cause sudden pain in one leg. In the lower legs and feet, the more common site, symptoms typically include numbness or tingling, usually symmetrical in both legs. Numbness can mask painful sensations, leading to unnoticed and worsening foot sores. Diabetic neuropathy can make walking challenging, but paradoxically, leg pain may improve with exercise in some cases.
Individuals with diabetes can reduce their neuropathy risk by diligently managing their blood sugar levels. The benefit of tight blood sugar control after nerve damage is less certain, but it remains crucial for overall health and preventing other diabetes-related complications. Pain management for neuropathy often involves pain relievers, tricyclic antidepressants (amitriptyline, desipramine, duloxetine), and anticonvulsants (carbamazepine, gabapentin, pregabalin) to control burning and tingling sensations.
Image: lzf/Getty Images
