The shocking death of Bobby Simone (Jimmy Smits) on “NYPD Blue” remains a landmark moment in television history. But why did Jimmy Smits leave the acclaimed police drama? This article delves into the reasons behind his departure, the creative decisions that led to Simone’s tragic demise, and the lasting impact of the episode “Hearts and Souls.”
Fifteen years after the episode aired, the emotional resonance of Simone’s death continues to be felt by both viewers and those involved in its creation. Smits chose to leave “NYPD Blue” after five Emmy-nominated seasons to pursue other acting opportunities. However, the way his character’s story ended was far from ordinary.
Series co-creator David Milch envisioned a realistic portrayal of death, inspired by his own father’s passing. Simone’s decline, stemming from a heart condition that necessitated a transplant and subsequently led to a fatal brain infection, unfolded over several episodes. This allowed for a nuanced exploration of not only the emotional toll on Simone’s wife, Diane (Kim Delaney), and his colleagues, but also the complex realities of the healthcare system.
Milch incorporated subtle yet powerful commentary on the political maneuvering within the medical profession, highlighting the conflict between Simone’s personal physician advocating for comfort and a hospital administrator prioritizing statistics. This added layer of realism resonated with viewers accustomed to the show’s insightful portrayal of law enforcement dynamics.
Smits praises Milch’s “brilliance” in making Simone’s physical and mental deterioration palpable, citing a poignant scene where Simone’s thirst is quenched before Diane even brings water to his lips due to the brain infection. The episode also delved into the spiritual aspects of dying, exploring themes of second winds, connecting with loved ones, and the possibility of an afterlife.
Director Paris Barclay, who won Emmy and Directors Guild of America awards for “Hearts and Souls,” remembers the emotional weight of filming the episode. The cast’s genuine affection for Smits translated into powerful on-screen moments, particularly the heartbreaking goodbye scene between Simone and Sipowicz (Dennis Franz). Barclay recalls having to separate the actors to maintain the somber atmosphere of the hospital setting and limit the number of takes to prevent excessive crying.
While Smits’ departure was planned, the “Hearts and Souls” episode masterfully crafted a realistic and emotionally resonant ending for Bobby Simone. It showcased the show’s commitment to authentic storytelling and provided a platform for Smits to deliver a performance that continues to be remembered as one of television’s most powerful portrayals of death and loss. The episode served as a testament to the strength of the writing, directing, and acting, solidifying its place as a pivotal moment in television history.
