Netflix’s 13 Reasons Why became a cultural phenomenon when it first premiered, largely due to its unflinching exploration of teen suicide through the eyes of Hannah Baker (portrayed by Katherine Langford). The series, adapted from Jay Asher’s novel, initially presented a compelling, albeit controversial, narrative around the events leading to Hannah’s tragic decision. At the heart of the story is a series of cassette tapes, a posthumous suicide note detailing “13 reasons why” Hannah chose to end her life, each reason pointing to a specific individual and their actions.
While 13 Reasons Why has faced increasing scrutiny over its graphic content and potential impact on young viewers – leading to the eventual removal of Hannah’s suicide scene – its first season remains a powerful, if disturbing, examination of bullying, sexual assault, and the devastating consequences of inaction and unkindness. The show uses Hannah’s tapes to unfold a complex web of interpersonal conflicts and systemic failures that contributed to her despair. Let’s delve into each of Hannah Baker’s 13 reasons, understanding the cascade of events that led to her tragic end.
13 Reasons Why Season 4 Ending Clay Zach Jessica
The 13 Tapes: Hannah Baker’s Reasons for Suicide
Hannah Baker’s narrative is meticulously structured around 13 cassette tapes, each side dedicated to a person she believes played a role in her suicide. These tapes, delivered to her classmate Clay Jensen (Dylan Minnette), unveil a series of interconnected events, painting a grim picture of high school life and the cumulative effect of seemingly small acts of cruelty and neglect. Here’s a breakdown of each tape and the corresponding reason:
Tape 1 – Justin Foley: The Devastating Rumor
Hannah’s first reason begins with Justin Foley (Brandon Flynn), marking the genesis of her tarnished reputation at Liberty High. In “Tape 1, Side A,” Hannah recounts her initial positive encounter with Justin at a party hosted by her friend Kat. As the new girl in town, Hannah is eager to make connections, and Justin appears to be a promising start. After a date at a park, Justin captures a photo of Hannah on a slide, a seemingly innocent moment that takes a dark turn.
Yielding to peer pressure, Justin shares the photograph, subtly implying a sexual encounter beyond a simple kiss. This malicious rumor spreads rapidly, instantly damaging Hannah’s reputation and casting a shadow over her interactions at school. This initial betrayal by Justin is not just about a first kiss gone wrong; it’s about the immediate and widespread damage caused by gossip and the casual disregard for someone’s personal boundaries and reputation.
Tape 2 – Jessica Davis: Betrayal and Bullying
Tape 1, Side B, focuses on Jessica Davis (Alisha Boe), highlighting the painful loss of friendship and the sting of misplaced blame. Jessica, another newcomer, initially forms a close bond with Hannah, and they are later joined by Alex Standall (Miles Heizer) to create the “FML Club.” However, the dynamics shift when Jessica and Alex begin dating, leading to Hannah’s gradual exclusion.
When Alex and Jessica’s relationship ends, Jessica, fueled by unfounded jealousy and suspicion, wrongly accuses Hannah of being involved with Alex. In a moment of anger and public humiliation, Jessica slaps Hannah, branding her with a derogatory slur. This act of aggression, coupled with the prevailing rumors initiated by Justin, intensifies Hannah’s isolation and solidifies the perception of her as someone with a damaged reputation, further contributing to her emotional distress.
Tape 3 – Alex Standall: The Hot List and Public Humiliation
Alex Standall takes center stage in Tape 2, Side A, revealing his contribution to Hannah’s public shaming. Seeking acceptance among the school’s jocks, Alex creates “The Hot List,” a ranking of girls in the school based on their perceived attractiveness. In a particularly cruel move aimed at hurting Jessica, Alex includes Hannah in the “Best Ass” category and Jessica in the “Worst Ass” category.
This list, circulated throughout the school, amplifies the rumors surrounding Hannah’s sexuality and turns her into an object of unwanted attention and ridicule. The “Hot List” not only perpetuates the damaging gossip but also objectifies Hannah, stripping her of her dignity and making her feel like nothing more than a body to be judged and ranked. This public humiliation intensifies the harassment Hannah experiences and deepens her sense of worthlessness.
Tape 4 – Tyler Down: Stalking and Photo Leak
Tape 2, Side B, unveils the unsettling actions of Tyler Down (Devin Druid), a character who embodies the dangers of unchecked obsession and invasion of privacy. Tyler, the school photographer, develops an unhealthy fixation on Hannah after she shows him a moment of kindness. Unable to express his feelings in a healthy way, Tyler resorts to stalking Hannah and secretly taking photographs of her.
One of these clandestine photos captures a kiss between Hannah and Courtney Crimsen (Michele Selene Ang) during a game of Truth or Dare. When Hannah confronts Tyler and rejects his advances, he retaliates by leaking the photograph throughout the school. While the subjects are not immediately recognizable to everyone, the photo adds another layer to the rumors surrounding Hannah and further isolates her, particularly damaging any chance of friendship with Courtney and increasing her anxiety and depression.
Tape 5 – Courtney Crimsen: The Web of Lies
The fallout from Tyler’s leaked photo is explored in Tape 3, Side A, focusing on Courtney Crimsen’s damaging response. Courtney, fearing social repercussions due to her upbringing by gay parents, is desperate to distance herself from the photograph and any association with Hannah. When confronted about the photo and her relationship with Hannah, Courtney fabricates an elaborate web of lies to protect her own reputation.
Courtney’s lies not only betray Hannah’s trust but also actively contribute to the harmful rumors already circulating. She falsely portrays Hannah as promiscuous and reinforces the damaging narrative that was taking root, adding fuel to the fire of Hannah’s already precarious social standing. This betrayal from someone Hannah might have considered a friend deepens her sense of isolation and despair.
Tape 6 – Marcus Cole: The Attempted Assault and Reputation Tarnish
Tape 3, Side B, introduces Marcus Cole (Steven Silver), illustrating how even seemingly positive interactions could turn predatory and damaging for Hannah. Initially appearing as a charming and accomplished student, Marcus arranges a Valentine’s Day date with Hannah. However, his true intentions are quickly revealed when he arrives late with a group of his jock friends, turning the date into a spectacle.
Throughout the evening, Marcus’s behavior becomes increasingly inappropriate, with unwanted physical advances and a dismissive attitude towards Hannah’s boundaries. When Hannah firmly rejects his advances, Marcus, angered and entitled, preemptively damages her reputation further to protect his own ego. He spreads rumors painting Hannah as easy and undesirable, compounding the existing harassment and solidifying the pervasive negative perception of her.
Tape 7 – Zach Dempsey: Stealing Hannah’s Lifeline
Zach Dempsey (Ross Butler) is the subject of Tape 4, Side A, highlighting a more subtle yet deeply impactful betrayal. Zach was present during Marcus and Hannah’s disastrous date and, unlike the others, attempts to console Hannah afterward. A connection forms between them, offering Hannah a glimmer of hope amidst her growing despair.
However, when Hannah misinterprets Zach’s romantic interest as another consequence of the rumors and rebuffs him publicly, Zach retaliates in a particularly cruel way. He steals anonymous, encouraging notes (secretly written by Clay) that Hannah had been receiving in class. Hannah describes these notes as a “lifeline” during her escalating depression, and Zach’s act of theft removes this source of comfort and hope, delivering a fresh and deeply personal blow.
Tape 8 – Ryan Shaver: Betrayal of Trust and Public Poem
Tape 4, Side B, reveals how even creative expression and vulnerability could be weaponized against Hannah, through the actions of Ryan Shaver (Tommy Dorfman). Hannah finds solace in writing poetry and joins a club where Ryan, the school newspaper editor, encourages her. He gains her trust and access to her personal writings.
Despite Hannah’s explicit refusal to have her poem published, Ryan, disregarding her wishes and betraying her trust, steals and publishes it in the school newspaper. This public exposure of her private thoughts and feelings, coupled with the ensuing mockery and speculation, intensifies Hannah’s embarrassment and sense of violation. She describes this betrayal as the moment that finally broke her spirit, extinguishing her remaining hope.
Tape 9 – Justin Foley Revisited: Witness to a Sexual Assault
Justin Foley reappears on Tape 5, Side A, in a far more serious and disturbing context, exposing his complicity in a sexual assault. Hannah recounts witnessing a horrific event at a party. Hiding in a closet to avoid unwanted attention, she overhears Justin and Jessica entering a room. After Justin leaves Jessica, Bryce Walker (Justin Prentice) arrives, demanding access. Justin, despite initial hesitation, allows Bryce to enter.
Bryce proceeds to rape a largely unconscious Jessica. Hannah, paralyzed by fear and guilt, remains hidden, witnessing the assault. While Justin’s initial hesitation might suggest some level of conscience, Hannah holds him responsible for enabling Bryce by allowing him into the room and for not doing more to protect Jessica. Hannah also carries the burden of her own inaction, feeling immense guilt for not intervening.
Tape 10 – Sheri Holland: The Fatal Accident
Tape 5, Side B, shifts focus to Sheri Holland (Ajiona Alexus), whose actions on the night of Jessica’s assault indirectly contribute to tragedy. Distraught after witnessing Bryce’s heinous act, Hannah accepts a ride home from Sheri. However, Sheri, distracted, knocks down a stop sign. Fearful of legal repercussions, Sheri prioritizes self-preservation over responsibility.
Despite Hannah’s pleas to report the incident, Sheri drives away, leaving Hannah stranded and the damaged stop sign unattended. This act of irresponsibility has devastating consequences when the missing stop sign leads to a car crash, resulting in the death of Jeff Atkins, Clay’s friend. Sheri’s fear and inaction have fatal repercussions, adding another layer of guilt and despair to Hannah’s already burdened psyche.
Tape 11 – Clay Jensen: The Guilt of Leaving
After a season of anticipation, Tape 6, Side A, finally reveals Clay Jensen’s role in Hannah’s tapes, highlighting the complexities of human interaction and the burden of perceived failure. The episode reveals that Clay was the reason Hannah was in Jessica’s room at the party. Having grown closer throughout the evening, they sought refuge in the bedroom. As their intimacy escalates, Hannah is overwhelmed by her accumulated trauma and experiences a breakdown.
In her distress, Hannah abruptly tells Clay to leave. Confused and hurt, Clay complies, a decision that haunts him with immense guilt. Hannah acknowledges on the tape that a part of her wished Clay would have stayed, but she explicitly states that Clay does not deserve to be on the tapes in the same way as the others. She explains that he is included because he was a significant part of her story. Despite Hannah’s understanding, Clay struggles with self-blame, agonizing over whether staying could have altered the subsequent tragic events.
Tape 12 – Bryce Walker: The Brutal Rape
Tape 6, Side B, centers on Bryce Walker, the most egregious perpetrator in Hannah’s narrative and arguably the central reason for her suicide. Already grappling with financial strain at her family’s store and deepening depression, Hannah finds herself at another party. After initially socializing with Jessica and others in a hot tub, she is left alone with Bryce.
When Hannah attempts to leave, Bryce prevents her and proceeds to rape her, mirroring his assault on Jessica and numerous other female students. Bryce Walker embodies the most extreme form of violation and disregard for Hannah’s autonomy and well-being. This brutal sexual assault is a pivotal and devastating event, representing the culmination of the relentless harassment and abuse Hannah has endured, solidifying Bryce as a primary catalyst for her suicide.
Tape 13 – Mr. Porter: The Failure of Help
The final tape, Tape 7, Side A, implicates Mr. Kevin Porter (Derek Luke), the school guidance counselor, representing a systemic failure of support and adult intervention. Although Hannah has already decided to end her life, she makes one last desperate attempt to seek help. She visits Mr. Porter, hoping for a lifeline.
However, Mr. Porter proves to be dismissive and inattentive, repeatedly distracted and offering superficial advice. Even when Hannah explicitly expresses her feelings of emptiness and despair, and alludes to her sexual assault, Mr. Porter fails to recognize the severity of her distress. He suggests she simply move on and forget the trauma. Hannah’s final plea for help is met with indifference and inadequate guidance. Mr. Porter’s failure to provide meaningful support in her moment of crisis represents a profound betrayal of trust and a devastating missed opportunity to intervene and potentially change Hannah’s fate.
The Removal of Hannah’s Death Scene and the Show’s Message
The graphic depiction of Hannah’s suicide in 13 Reasons Why sparked considerable controversy and debate regarding its potential impact on vulnerable viewers. Responding to concerns raised by mental health experts and viewers, Netflix ultimately removed the scene, emphasizing a commitment to prioritizing audience well-being over graphic content. This edit aimed to refocus the narrative on the underlying message of the show: the critical importance of empathy, support, and taking better care of one another.
While the removal of such a pivotal scene inevitably alters the viewing experience, it underscores the producers’ intent to shift the focus from the act of suicide itself to the complex web of factors that contribute to suicidal ideation. 13 Reasons Why, even without the graphic depiction, remains a stark reminder of the profound impact of bullying, sexual assault, and the critical need for effective mental health support systems and compassionate communities. The show’s legacy, particularly in its first season, lies in its unflinching portrayal of teen struggles and its urgent call for greater understanding and proactive intervention in the lives of young people facing adversity.
The Shift Beyond Hannah and the Show’s Decline
While the first season of 13 Reasons Why garnered critical acclaim and sparked important conversations, subsequent seasons, diverging significantly from the source material, faced diminishing returns. Seasons 3 and 4 moved away from Hannah’s tapes and transformed the series into more of a conventional teen drama, incorporating murder mystery elements and shifting focus to other characters and storylines.
The shift away from Hannah’s perspective, which was so powerfully conveyed through her tapes in the first season, arguably weakened the show’s unique voice and impact. The initial season’s strength lay in its intimate portrayal of Hannah’s pain and the audience’s forced confrontation with the consequences of seemingly minor actions. As the series broadened its scope and introduced new characters and plotlines, it lost some of the focused intensity and emotional resonance that defined its debut. Despite efforts to address themes of trauma and healing, the later seasons struggled to recapture the critical success and cultural impact of the first season, which was deeply rooted in understanding “why Hannah Baker killed herself.”
