Why Do People Sleep With Their Eyes Open? Understanding Nocturnal Lagophthalmos

It’s a common image of peaceful slumber: eyes gently closed, the world shut out as we drift into restorative rest. Therefore, it might come as a surprise to learn that for some individuals, this isn’t the case. A significant number of people actually sleep with their eyes partially or fully open, a condition known as nocturnal lagophthalmos. In fact, studies suggest that approximately 1 in 20 people experience this phenomenon, raising questions about why it happens and what it means for their health.

The Crucial Role of Closed Eyelids During Sleep

Our eyelids are more than just facial features; they are essential protectors of our eyes, especially during sleep, which is a vulnerable time for the body. Closing our eyes is a fundamental aspect of healthy sleep, serving several critical functions that contribute to both eye health and overall rest quality.

Firstly, eyelids act as a physical barrier against the external environment. Throughout the day, our eyes are exposed to dust, debris, and potential irritants. During sleep, closed eyelids continue this protective role, preventing foreign particles from entering and potentially damaging the delicate surface of the eye. This protective function is crucial for maintaining eye hygiene and preventing infections.

Beyond physical protection, eyelids play a vital role in maintaining eye lubrication. Our eyes need constant moisture to function properly and comfortably. When we are awake, we blink regularly, spreading tears across the eye surface to keep it hydrated. However, blinking frequency decreases significantly during sleep. Closed eyelids help to trap moisture, preventing the eyes from drying out overnight. This is essential because excessive dryness can lead to discomfort, irritation, and even damage to the cornea, the clear front surface of the eye.

Perhaps most importantly in the context of sleep, closing our eyes is intrinsically linked to our body’s sleep-wake cycle, also known as the circadian rhythm. Light is a powerful cue that regulates this internal clock. Specialized cells in the retina of our eyes are sensitive to light and transmit signals to the hypothalamus, a brain region that controls various bodily functions, including sleep. These signals essentially tell our body it’s daytime and time to be awake. Conversely, darkness triggers the production of melatonin, a hormone that promotes sleepiness. By blocking out light, closed eyelids reinforce the darkness signal, facilitating the onset and maintenance of sleep. This process ensures that our sleep is aligned with the natural day-night cycle, which is crucial for optimal health and well-being.

Nocturnal Lagophthalmos Defined

Nocturnal lagophthalmos is the medical term for the inability to close the eyelids completely during sleep. The term itself breaks down into “nocturnal,” meaning nighttime, and “lagophthalmos,” derived from Greek words “lago” (hare) and “ophthalmos” (eye), alluding to the myth that hares sleep with their eyes open. While some people may experience minor eyelid opening that goes unnoticed, nocturnal lagophthalmos refers to a more significant and persistent condition where the eyes remain partially or fully open throughout the night.

It’s important to differentiate nocturnal lagophthalmos from situations where eyes might be momentarily open during sleep, such as during episodes of sleepwalking or REM (Rapid Eye Movement) sleep. Sleepwalking, while often involving open eyes, is a distinct parasomnia, a sleep disorder characterized by abnormal behaviors during sleep. Similarly, brief eye movements and even slight openings can occur during REM sleep, the stage associated with dreaming, but these are typically transient and not indicative of lagophthalmos. Nocturnal lagophthalmos is characterized by the eyelids remaining open for a considerable portion of the sleep period, leading to potential symptoms and complications.

Unpacking the Causes of Sleeping With Eyes Open

Nocturnal lagophthalmos is not a condition in itself, but rather a symptom of an underlying issue that prevents the eyelids from closing properly. The reasons behind this inability to close the eyes completely are varied and can stem from different factors affecting eyelid mechanics, nerve function, or even structural changes in the face. Understanding these causes is crucial for effective diagnosis and treatment.

Several conditions and factors can predispose individuals to nocturnal lagophthalmos:

Proptosis (Bulging Eyeball): When the eyeball protrudes further forward than normal, it creates a larger surface area that the eyelids need to cover. This protrusion, known as proptosis or exophthalmos, can be caused by various conditions. Graves’ disease, an autoimmune disorder affecting the thyroid gland, is a common cause of proptosis. Congenital conditions affecting the facial bone structure can also lead to bulging eyes. Infections or tumors in the eye socket are less frequent but possible causes. When the eyeball protrudes, the eyelids may not be long enough or have sufficient mobility to close completely over it.
Short or Weak Eyelids: The ability of the eyelids to close depends on their size, shape, and muscle tone. Conditions that shorten the eyelids or weaken the muscles responsible for eyelid closure can result in lagophthalmos. Certain medical procedures can inadvertently affect eyelid function. For instance, eyelid-tightening surgery (blepharoplasty) may, in some cases, remove too much skin, leading to reduced eyelid closure. Botox injections around the eyes, while often used for cosmetic purposes, can temporarily weaken the muscles that close the eyelids. Fat removal around the eyes can also alter eyelid structure and function. Furthermore, general muscle weakness conditions can affect the muscles responsible for eyelid closure, although this is a less common direct cause of nocturnal lagophthalmos.
Scarring: Scar tissue on the eyelids can restrict their movement and flexibility, making complete closure difficult. Physical trauma to the eyelids, such as cuts or abrasions, can lead to scarring. Chemical burns to the face and eyelids can also cause significant scarring that impairs eyelid function. Certain systemic diseases, such as ocular pemphigoid and Stevens-Johnson syndrome, can cause scarring of the conjunctiva, the membrane lining the eyelids and covering the white part of the eye, which can also limit eyelid closure.
Nerve Problems: The muscles that control eyelid movement are innervated by facial nerves. Damage or dysfunction of these nerves can lead to weakness or paralysis of the eyelid muscles, preventing proper closure. Bell’s palsy, a condition characterized by sudden weakness or paralysis of facial muscles, is a well-known cause of facial nerve dysfunction and can result in lagophthalmos. Lyme disease, an infection transmitted by ticks, can also affect facial nerves and cause similar symptoms. Injuries to the facial nerves, whether from surgery, trauma, or other causes, can also impair eyelid function. Various neurological disorders affecting facial nerve pathways can also contribute to this issue.
Sedatives: Certain substances can relax the muscles in the body, including those that control the eyelids. Excessive alcohol consumption can have a muscle-relaxant effect and, in some individuals, contribute to nocturnal lagophthalmos. Similarly, some sedatives, including certain types of sleeping pills, can also relax eyelid muscles and increase the likelihood of sleeping with eyes partially open. This effect is usually temporary and resolves as the substance is metabolized by the body.
Idiopathic Nocturnal Lagophthalmos: In some cases, no underlying cause for nocturnal lagophthalmos can be identified despite thorough examination. When the cause remains unknown, the condition is classified as idiopathic. Idiopathic nocturnal lagophthalmos is not uncommon, and while the exact mechanism is unclear, it may involve subtle, unidentified issues with eyelid muscle tone or nerve function.

It’s important to note that while sleepwalking can involve open eyes, it is not considered a cause of nocturnal lagophthalmos. The eye-opening in sleepwalking is typically a transient feature of the sleepwalking episode itself, rather than a persistent inability to close the eyelids during sleep. These are distinct conditions with different underlying mechanisms.

person stretching

Recognizing the Signs: Symptoms of Sleeping With Your Eyes Open

Not everyone who sleeps with their eyes open experiences noticeable symptoms. The severity of symptoms associated with nocturnal lagophthalmos can vary significantly depending on the extent of eyelid opening, the duration of the condition, and individual factors such as age and tear production. Many younger individuals with mild nocturnal lagophthalmos may experience minimal to no symptoms, especially if their tear production is adequate. However, as we age, tear quality and production naturally tend to decrease, making older adults more susceptible to experiencing symptoms even with milder forms of nocturnal lagophthalmos.

Symptoms of nocturnal lagophthalmos are typically most pronounced in the morning, upon waking, and tend to improve throughout the day as blinking and tear production rehydrate the eyes. Common symptoms include:

Dry Eyes: This is the most frequent and characteristic symptom. The lack of complete eyelid closure allows tears to evaporate overnight, leading to a sensation of dryness, grittiness, or a feeling like something is in the eye.
Sore or Painful Eyes: Persistent dryness and irritation can lead to soreness or even pain in the eyes. This discomfort may range from mild to more intense, depending on the severity of the dryness and any corneal involvement.
A Feeling of Irritation: Beyond dryness, the eyes may feel generally irritated, itchy, or uncomfortable. This sensation can be constant or intermittent and may be exacerbated by environmental factors like dry air or wind.
Watery Eyes: Paradoxically, dry eyes can sometimes trigger excessive tearing. This is the body’s reflex response to dryness, attempting to compensate for the lack of lubrication by producing more tears. However, these reflex tears are often of poor quality and may not effectively alleviate the underlying dryness.
Blurry Vision: Dryness can disrupt the smooth surface of the cornea, which is essential for clear vision. This can result in temporary blurry vision, particularly upon waking. Blinking and rehydration of the eye surface usually improve vision throughout the day.
Red Eyes: Chronic dryness and irritation can cause inflammation of the conjunctiva, leading to redness of the eyes. The eyes may appear bloodshot or have visible red veins.

If left unaddressed, chronic nocturnal lagophthalmos can have more serious consequences for eye health. Persistent dryness can damage the cornea, leading to a condition called keratitis, which is inflammation of the cornea. Keratitis, in turn, increases the risk of developing corneal ulcers, open sores on the cornea that can be painful and potentially sight-threatening. In severe cases, prolonged and untreated nocturnal lagophthalmos can even lead to corneal perforation, a hole in the cornea, and ultimately, vision loss.

Furthermore, studies have shown a link between nocturnal lagophthalmos and poor sleep quality. The discomfort and irritation associated with dry eyes can disrupt sleep, making it harder to fall asleep and stay asleep. Some research suggests that even the minimal amount of light entering through partially open eyelids can interfere with sleep by causing visual stimulation and arousal, further fragmenting sleep and reducing its restorative quality.

Diagnosing Nocturnal Lagophthalmos: What to Expect

Diagnosing nocturnal lagophthalmos typically involves a comprehensive eye examination by an eye doctor (ophthalmologist or optometrist). Self-diagnosis can be challenging, as subtle eyelid openings may be difficult to detect, even if someone else observes you sleeping. Therefore, if you suspect you might be sleeping with your eyes open, or if you are experiencing persistent eye symptoms, seeking professional evaluation is crucial.

The diagnostic process usually begins with the doctor observing your eyes from a distance to assess eyelid position and closure. They will then engage in a detailed discussion about your symptoms, including when they occur, their severity, and any factors that seem to worsen or improve them. The doctor will also inquire about your medical history, looking for predisposing conditions such as thyroid disorders, facial nerve problems, or a history of eyelid surgery or trauma. Family history of similar eye conditions may also be relevant.

Based on this initial consultation, the doctor will likely perform a slit lamp examination. This procedure utilizes a specialized microscope with a bright light source to examine the structures of the eye in detail, including the eyelids, cornea, conjunctiva, and tear film. The slit lamp allows the doctor to assess the extent of eyelid closure, identify any corneal damage or dryness, and evaluate the overall health of the eye surface.

The doctor may also ask you to blink and observe the completeness and frequency of your blinks. They may gently manipulate your eyelids with gloved hands to assess eyelid laxity, muscle strength, and look for any signs of facial nerve dysfunction that might be contributing to incomplete closure. Specific tests to evaluate tear production and tear film quality may also be performed to assess the extent of dryness and its potential contribution to your symptoms.

A thorough assessment is essential for accurate diagnosis and for developing an individualized treatment plan tailored to the underlying cause and severity of your nocturnal lagophthalmos.

Treatment Strategies for Sleeping With Your Eyes Open

The treatment approach for nocturnal lagophthalmos is highly individualized and depends on identifying and addressing the underlying cause of the condition, as well as managing the symptoms and preventing potential complications. The primary goals of treatment are to alleviate dry eye symptoms, protect the cornea from damage, and improve overall eye comfort and sleep quality.

If an underlying medical condition is identified as the cause of nocturnal lagophthalmos, treating that condition is the first priority. For example, if proptosis due to Graves’ disease is the culprit, managing the thyroid disorder may improve eyelid closure. If facial nerve damage is the cause, consultation with a neurologist may be necessary to address the nerve issue.

Regardless of the underlying cause, symptomatic treatment to manage dry eyes is typically the cornerstone of nocturnal lagophthalmos management. This often involves:

Eye Drops and Ointments: Artificial tears, available over-the-counter, are frequently recommended to provide lubrication during waking hours. These drops help to supplement natural tears and keep the eye surface moist. For nighttime lubrication, thicker lubricating ointments are often prescribed. Ointments provide longer-lasting moisture and protection overnight when tear production is reduced and evaporation is more likely.
Eyelid Tape or Moisture Goggles: In more severe cases, or when eye drops and ointments are insufficient, doctors may recommend using special eyelid tape to gently keep the eyes closed during sleep. This tape is designed to be safe for use on the delicate eyelid skin and helps to prevent nighttime eye opening. Alternatively, moisture goggles or sleep masks that create a moisture-rich environment around the eyes can be used to reduce tear evaporation overnight.
Environmental Adjustments: Modifying your sleeping environment can also help to alleviate dry eye symptoms. Using a humidifier in the bedroom can increase air humidity and reduce tear evaporation. Positioning your bed away from direct airflow from vents or fans can also minimize eye dryness. Ensuring the bedroom is dark is important for promoting sleep in general, and it may also be beneficial for individuals with nocturnal lagophthalmos to minimize any potential light exposure through partially open eyelids.
Lifestyle Modifications: Certain lifestyle changes can be helpful. Limiting alcohol and sedatives, especially close to bedtime, can reduce muscle relaxation and potentially improve eyelid closure. Maintaining good eye hygiene by keeping the eyes clean and free of debris is always important, but particularly so when lubrication is compromised. Consciously practicing blinking more frequently and fully during waking hours can help to stimulate tear production and improve overall eye moisture.
Surgical Interventions: In a minority of cases, when conservative treatments are not sufficient, or when there is a structural issue preventing eyelid closure, surgical options may be considered. These procedures are typically reserved for more severe cases and are generally well-tolerated and effective. Surgical techniques include skin grafting to add tissue to the eyelids, sewing the eyelids partially together (tarsorrhaphy) to narrow the eyelid opening, or implanting tiny gold weights into the upper eyelids to assist with eyelid closure by gravity.

When to Seek Professional Advice

Nocturnal lagophthalmos can be a subtle condition, and as mentioned earlier, self-diagnosis can be difficult. If you are experiencing persistent eye symptoms, particularly dry eyes that are worse in the morning, or if you suspect that you might be sleeping with your eyes partially open, it is advisable to consult an eye doctor. Prompt diagnosis and appropriate management are crucial to protect your eye health and ensure quality sleep. Untreated nocturnal lagophthalmos can lead to significant eye discomfort, potential corneal damage, and compromised vision over time. Seeking professional help will allow for accurate diagnosis, identification of any underlying causes, and the development of a personalized treatment plan to address your specific needs and help you achieve comfortable, healthy eyes and restful sleep.

Still have questions? Ask our community!

Join our Sleep Care Community — a trusted hub of sleep health professionals, product specialists, and people just like you. Whether you need expert sleep advice for your insomnia or you’re searching for the perfect mattress, we’ve got you covered. Get personalized guidance from the experts who know sleep best.