Major Outer Banks season 4 part 2 spoilers ahead. Seriously, the biggest spoiler of the whole series is coming.
Outer Banks Season 4 has concluded, leaving fans reeling from an emotionally charged finale. After four seasons of thrilling escapades across the OBX and beyond, navigating treacherous storms, finally locating the Blue Crown, and even witnessing a glimmer of reconciliation with Rafe, viewers were forced to bid farewell to a beloved Pogue in part 2. The emotional impact of this loss is profound, leaving many questioning if they can even revisit the show. Let’s delve into the specifics of the shocking Outer Banks Season 4 ending and address the burning question: Why Did Jj Die?
Unpacking the Outer Banks Season 4 Ending
- Outer Banks season 4 part 2 premiered on Netflix on November 7.
- Amidst numerous plot twists, the series delivered a devastating blow by killing off a fan-favorite character.
- Discover the reasons behind this tragic decision, described as “the overarching plan for the show.”
Was Rudy Pankow’s Departure from OBX Inevitable?
Image: JJ and Kiara face danger in the Outer Banks Season 4 finale, hinting at the tragic events to come.
The quest for the Blue Crown led the Pogues (and Rafe, tentatively included in their ranks) to Morocco, placing them once more in opposition to Chandler Groff and the formidable duo of Dalia & Lightener. Amidst the high-stakes adventure, cherished pairings like JJ and Kiara found moments of connection, sharing dreams of wish-granting legends tied to the crown. However, as the group edged closer to deciphering the treasure map, a violent sandstorm scattered them. Sarah and John B. found themselves pursued by Dalia’s henchmen, while Pope and Cleo confronted Lightener, leaving JJ and Kiara to pursue the crown.
Against the odds, JJ succeeded in his mission, locating the elusive crown and escaping Dalia’s grasp with Kiara. But their triumph was short-lived. Confronted by Groff, who threatened Kiara with a knife, JJ faced an impossible choice: the treasure or the love of his life. In a heart-wrenching echo of their season 1 bond, JJ willingly relinquished the crown to ensure Kiara’s safety. However, in a brutal act of cruelty, Groff stabbed JJ regardless, leaving him mortally wounded in Kiara’s arms as Groff fled with the prize.
This scene stands as one of the most emotionally devastating moments in recent television. Kiara cradled JJ as he struggled for breath, his final words a testament to his love for her and his concern for his Pogue family. He declared his wish had already been granted – her. With final declarations of love, JJ passed away, leaving viewers in floods of tears.
Image: A close-up shot of Rudy Pankow as JJ Maybank, highlighting the emotional depth of his character in Outer Banks.
Showrunner Shannon Burke described the scene’s deliberate impact to EW, stating, “It’s something that’s engineered to be gratuitous. JJ totally is at peace, that’s the intent. He’s gotten past this. He’s been in a bad place and has been spinning for a lot of the season…And you feel when he comes back [after saving Sarah] that he’s in a better place and that there’s a long and bright future with him and Kiara, so it makes it extra tragic, what happens.” Indeed, “extra tragic” is an understatement.
In a Deadline interview, Burke elaborated on the narrative arc: “We wanted to begin in a place of innocence and then go to a place that at least one point to go is really dark for [the kids], and then have them come out of it. That’s the overarching plan for the show. It was always JJ that was going to be, we just weren’t sure how we were going to play it.” This confirms that JJ’s death was not a last-minute decision but a planned element of the series’ overarching narrative.
Image: Rudy Pankow as JJ Maybank in Outer Banks, capturing the character’s vulnerability and emotional range.
The decision to kill off JJ sparked significant backlash from fans, many feeling it was rushed and that his relationships with the group had been underdeveloped this season. Adding fuel to the fire, rumors from a DeuxMoi source suggest JJ’s death was originally slated for the series finale. However, cast drama rumors surrounding Rudy Pankow allegedly led to him requesting an early exit from the show.
According to the source, “They filmed episode 10 before the last episodes of the first half & Rudy didn’t tell the cast so it threw them off. In the last episode you can see how mad everyone was at Rudy. It’s a mess and it pissed off production but they are going to brush it off like it’s ‘always been the plan.’” While these remain unconfirmed rumors, they add another layer of complexity to the already controversial storyline of why JJ died.
Could JJ Return in Season 5? Hope vs. Reality
Image: The question “Is Rudy Pankow leaving OBX?” posed with an image of JJ, reflecting fan speculation about his character’s fate.
Despite the seemingly definitive nature of JJ’s death – John B. checked his pulse, and Rafe was shown digging his grave – some fans cling to hope for his resurrection. Outer Banks has seen characters like Ward, Big John, and Sarah defy death before, albeit with varying degrees of believability. The introduction of the Blue Crown, rumored to grant wishes, has further fueled speculation. Could Kie and the Pogues use its power to bring JJ back to life?
One X user’s viral thread points out, “Why would they create a treasure with the power of invincibility and wishes if it wasn’t significant? So either Chandler finds JJ’s body in Morocco and uses the crown on him or Kie / the Pogues will wish for JJ’s life back.”
Referencing Stranger Things 4‘s spectral return of Billy, showrunner Shannon Burke acknowledged the possibility of Rudy Pankow’s return in some capacity to EW: “I wouldn’t put [Rudy Pankow’s return] out of the realm of possibility. I wouldn’t say for sure but I wouldn’t be surprised if it happened.” This leaves the door slightly ajar for flashbacks, dream sequences, or even a more fantastical revival, though the latter would represent a significant shift in the show’s established tone.
Beyond JJ’s Fate: Other Key Developments in the Finale
Image: Madelyn Cline as Sarah Cameron in Outer Banks Season 4, focusing on her character’s pregnancy.
Amidst the heartbreak of “the fandom’s favorite character”’s death, it’s easy to overlook other significant developments in the finale. Yes, Sarah Cameron is pregnant! Season 5 will undoubtedly explore this new chapter for her and John B. The poignant detail of JJ, the baby’s godfather, suggesting his own name as a gender-neutral option adds another layer of sorrow to his loss, while hinting at a possible way to honor his memory.
The Pogues’ Future: Revenge and Redemption
Image: The core Outer Banks cast, emphasizing the group dynamic and their journey through season 4.
Beyond Sarah’s pregnancy, the finale saw Sarah and Rafe begin to mend their fractured relationship, finding themselves unexpectedly united in Morocco. Cleo achieved a measure of closure regarding Terrance’s murder with Lightener’s demise, although Pope will bear the consequences. Pope’s act of killing Lightener marked a significant turning point, contrasting with John B.’s inability to take a life earlier in the season. With Pope now a fugitive from both the police and the Marines, his future hangs precariously in the balance.
However, the showrunners have offered a glimpse into the central theme of Outer Banks season 5: revenge.
Outer Banks Season 5: A Path of Revenge?
Image: Madison Bailey as Kiara “Kie” Carrera, showcasing her character’s determination and possible shift towards revenge in Outer Banks.
Jonas Pate revealed to Deadline, “[Revenge] is where we start but I think it will go through different iterations. If you look at The Count of Monte Cristo, one of the greatest revenge stories, you start with revenge, but it goes to understanding and forgiveness, so revenge goes on to different iterations of that, but revenge is where we start for sure.”
The final scene of Outer Banks season 4 depicts the Pogues gathered around a fire, grappling with the aftermath of JJ’s death. Kiara’s chilling vow to avenge JJ marks a profound shift in her character. As Shannon Burke noted to EW, “What’s interesting about her is she’s this ‘save the turtles, save the dolphins’ kind of person, and when you see her at the end of [season] 4, she definitely does not look that like anymore. She has turned into a different person and we’re excited for that and [Madison Bailey’s] really excited for that.”
Co-creators Josh and Jonas Pate further elaborated to Netflix, “We’re planning a story of redemption, and a season that embodies the friendship that JJ had come to represent. JJ’s death was a hard but necessary piece of the architecture for the story, and we plan on honoring that as much as we can because we love the character as much as the fans do.”
What are your thoughts on the Outer Banks season 4 ending and JJ’s death? Share your reactions on Instagram.
This post has been updated.
