The mid-season premiere of Yellowstone season 5 delivered a gut-wrenching blow to fans with the unexpected death of Colby, played by Denim Richards. This seemingly simple tragedy, occurring amidst a season of high-stakes drama and power plays, has left viewers wondering: why did the writers choose to kill off this beloved ranch hand?
A Cowboy’s Life: Danger and Reality
Colby’s death, a freak accident involving a horse trampling, underscores the inherent risks of the cowboy lifestyle. Director Christina Voros described the scene as “gut-wrenching” and a “freak accident” to The Hollywood Reporter, highlighting the everyday dangers faced by those working on a ranch. While Yellowstone often showcases dramatic conflicts and power struggles, Colby’s demise serves as a stark reminder of the unpredictable nature of life in the American West. It wasn’t a shootout or a calculated murder, but a simple accident that tragically ended his life. This emphasizes the show’s commitment to portraying the realistic dangers of ranch work.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(749×0:751×2)/Denim-Richards-yellowstone-120324-2-14ec720050634d04a7e2dde334e1ad5b.jpg)
Denim Richards as Colby, a Yellowstone ranch hand.
Richards himself acknowledged the simplicity of Colby’s death in an interview with The Hollywood Reporter. He stated that the unexpected nature of the accident highlights the fragility of life and brings a sense of grounding to the show’s often heightened drama. “Sometimes the show’s stakes are so high that you can get lost in how high they are,” Richards explained.
Foreshadowing and Finality
Rip Wheeler’s reaction to Colby’s death, lamenting the dangerous nature of their profession and predicting it will one day claim his own life, sparked speculation about foreshadowing. Voros addressed this in her interview, acknowledging the audience’s tendency to interpret such statements as ominous signs after experiencing a series of losses. However, she stopped short of confirming any intentional foreshadowing.
Colby’s death, while sudden, also provided a sense of closure. In an interview with Entertainment Weekly, Richards revealed that he learned about his character’s fate just a day before receiving the script. He also drew a parallel to a scene in Season 3 where Colby was trampled by horses in a river, suggesting a poetic element to his character’s final moments.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(749×0:751×2)/Denim-Richards-yellowstone-120324-3-2f490c73787c4d4b87ff7bf86d77181f.jpg)
The Yellowstone ranch hands in season 1, including Colby (far right).
A Season of Loss
Colby’s death is not an isolated incident in Yellowstone‘s fifth season. The season premiere revealed the death of patriarch John Dutton, played by Kevin Costner, following the actor’s departure from the show. While John’s death was avenged with the subsequent killing of Sarah Atwood, the mastermind behind his demise, Colby’s passing serves as a reminder that not all losses on the Dutton Ranch are part of a larger power struggle. Sometimes, they are simply tragic consequences of a dangerous way of life.
Colby’s death, though unexpected and heartbreaking, reinforces the show’s themes of mortality, the harsh realities of ranch life, and the ever-present danger lurking in the shadows of the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch. It serves as a poignant reminder that even in a world of intense drama and political maneuvering, sometimes the simplest events can have the most profound impact.
